Winning Mind Training

  • Home
  • About
    • About Winning Mind
    • Testimonials
  • Blog
  • Courses Listing / Calendar
    • Training Schedule
    • Course Descriptions
      • Dare To Be Great Leadership: Strategies to Help Build and Sustain a Culture of Leading, Learning and Excellence
      • Dare to Be Great: Strategies for Creating a Culture of Leading
      • Dare To Be Great Leadership 2.0: Continuing the Journey of Building a Culture of Leading, Learning and Excellence
      • Dare To Be Great Leadership: Strategies to Help Build and Sustain a Culture of Leading, Learning and Excellence
      • Excellence In Training
      • Performance Enhancement Imagery
      • PPCT Threat Pattern Recognition Use of Force Instructor Course
      • Ground Fighting and A.C.E. Edged Weapons Defense Instructor Course
      • Lessons From Life’s Most Powerful Question
  • Resources
  • Contact Us

July 10, 2009 By Brian Willis

Judged By 12 or Carried By 6

Over the years I have heard the expression a number of times by officers who say they would rather be “Judged by 12, than carried by 6”. I am sure we are all familiar with this saying which refers to the fact that the officer would rather have their actions in a deadly force confrontation judged by a jury of 12 of their peers than lose the fight and be carried by 6 pall bearers at their funeral. The saying often comes up during discussions about the authority of the officer to use deadly force against a subject.

I agree with the principle that in a violent confrontation we need to act and win the fight rather than worry about what is going to happen following the event, however, the statement bothers me. The reason it bothers me is that it is often given in a flippant or defensive manner during when / then discussions on deadly force situations or during debriefings following scenarios.
When an officers uses this statement as articulation of what they did or ‘would do’ it tells me that the officer is unclear on their justification and authorities to take a life.  That is what really concerns me.
It may sound macho to say you would rather be tried by 12 than carried by 6 but, what if the 12 send you to jail for murder because you were unable to justify your actions. As you sit in your four foot by eight foot cell with your new roomie ‘bubba’ are you still so cocky. Are you still happy with the 12 option?

 

The message here is that officers must know their authorities to stop, detain, search, arrest, enter a residence and to use force. They must also have the ability to articulate the reasonableness of their actions based on the totality of circumstances. By articulation I am referring to the ability to tell the story and explain to the judge or the jury why what they did at that moment in time was reasonable for them. Totality of circumstances is the ‘big picture’, all the information that factored into the officers perception of the threat up to the point that the force was used.

 

As trainers we need to move officers away from these historical sayings that may ultimately be setting the officers up for failure. Train your officers what they can do. Teach your officers when they can use force. School your officers in the art of articulation. Set your officers up for success both in the event and in the courtroom.

 

There is an article on the “Art of Articulation” by myself and Darren Leggatt in the highly acclaimed book W.I.N. 2 Insights Into Training and Leading Warriors”  available at www.warriorspiritbooks.com:
Jpeg
Upcoming Excellence in Training Presentations and Courses:
  • October 5, IALEFI RTC Bend, Oregon – 4 hour presentation for Command level leaders on Excellence Through Training and a 4 hour presentation for trainers on Excellence in Training.
  • October 19 to 22, Mount Prospect, Illinois – Excellence in Training Course
  • November 16 to 20, Lake Oswego, Oregon – Excellence in Training and Verbal Trauma Control Course
  • November 30 to December 4, Edmonton, Alberta – Excellence in Training and Verbal Trauma Control Course
  • January 19 to 22, 2010 Madison, Wisconsin – Excellence in Training Course
P.S. The archive for the LawOfficer.com Webcast Use of Force Training and What’s Important Now and the Q and A’s are now available at  http://www.lawofficer.com/webcasts/Use_of_Force_and_Whats_Important_Now.html
Take care.
Brian Willis

Filed Under: Blog

Subscribe To Our Blog

Sign up to the Winning Mind Training blog to receive new articles, tips and posts directly to your email inbox.

Excellence In Training Blog

  • Are you intentional and deliberate about this? January 24, 2023
  • Working through the dissonance; uncomfortable, but necessary. January 17, 2023
  • Do you think of yourself as a coach? January 10, 2023
  • Are you reaching up, down and across? January 2, 2023
  • The third element of evidence based – research informed. December 27, 2022

Contact Winning Mind Training

Address:
246 Stewart Green S.W., Suite #2486
Calgary AB. Canada. T3H 3C8

Phone: 403-279-5954

Email: winningmind@mac.com

Connect With Us

  • Email
  • LinkedIn
  • RSS
  • Twitter

Winning Mind Training is a proud member of the Calgary Chamber of Commerce. To get more information and to find out how you can become a member of the Chamber of Commerce go to www.calgarychamber.com

Events

  • Lessons From Life's Most Powerful Question - Closed Workshop
    • Thursday, Feb 02, 2023
  • Dare To Be Great Leadership: Strategies to Build and Sustain a Culture of Leading, Learning and Excellence - Madison, WI
    • Monday, Feb 06, 2023 - Tuesday, Feb 07, 2023
    • Madison
  • Excellence in Training Course - Madison, WI
    • Wednesday, Feb 08, 2023 - Friday, Feb 10, 2023
    • Madison
  • Copyright © 2023 · Winning Mind Training